Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
Repashy Calcium Plus 17.6 oz is the better pick for multi-reptile keepers because its 1.1 lb tub covers a large collection without constant reordering, while the 6 oz jar suits keepers with one or two reptiles thanks to its higher calcium minimum of 20%. The 17.6 oz lists calcium at a minimum of 17% and vitamin D at 20,000 IU/lb, versus the 6 oz jar’s 20% calcium and the same 20,000 IU/lb of vitamin D.
- Choose the Repashy Calcium Plus 6 oz if you keep just one or two reptiles and want the higher calcium minimum of 20% in a smaller jar that stays fresher.
- Choose the Repashy Calcium Plus 17.6 oz if you keep multiple reptiles and want a 1.1 lb supply with calcium micro ground to about 3.5 microns for better stick.
I compared these two jars on three things I could check straight from the listed specs: calcium minimum percentage, vitamin D level, and jar size. The comparison is based on the manufacturer’s stated specifications, not on any hands-on testing.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: Repashy Calcium Plus 17.6 oz
Lowest cost per ounce at check current price on Amazon, which pays off fast across a multi-reptile collection — Check Price →
Runner-Up: Repashy Calcium Plus 6 oz
Same 4.8-star formula in a smaller jar at check current price on Amazon per ounce, best if you keep just one or two reptiles — Check Price →
Here’s how the two jars stack up side by side on the specs that actually matter for a multi-reptile setup.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | Repashy Calcium Plus 6 oz | Repashy Calcium Plus 17.6 |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Repashy | Repashy |
| Flavor | Calcium | Calcium |
| Item Form | Powder | Powder |
| Item Weight | 6 ounces | ✅ 17.6 ounces |
| Size | ✅ 6 Oz JAR | 1.1 Pound (Pack of 1) |
| Product Benefits | ✅ All-in-One Calcium Supplement with added Vitamins, Trace Minerals, and Carotenoids | — |
| Active Ingredients | — | ✅ Calcium Carbonate, Dried Kelp, Brewer’s Dried Yeast, RoseHips, Calendula Flowe |
The biggest difference is the calcium level: the 6 oz jar lists calcium at a minimum of 20%, while the 17.6 oz jar lists 17% — so check which formula your reptiles need before you buy based on size alone.
Individual Product Breakdown
I looked at the same three things for each jar: how much you get, what it costs per ounce, and whether the formula matches what’s actually listed on the label. Here’s what I found.
Repashy Calcium Plus 6 oz JAR
6 oz JAR | 4.8 stars (467 ratings) | Calcium min. 20% | Vitamin D min. 20,000 IU/lb
- Calcium min. 20%, Sodium min. 1%, Magnesium min. .3%, Manganese min. 350 mg/kg, Zinc min. 350 mg/kg...
This is the jar I’d hand to someone with one or two reptiles. It’s the same all-in-one dusting powder — calcium, vitamins, trace minerals, and carotenoids in one step — and it lists calcium at a minimum of 20%, which is higher than the bigger jar’s 17%. The catch is the per-ounce math: you’re paying check current price on Amazon per ounce here versus a much lower rate on the 17.6 oz. If you dust insects a few times a week, this jar lasts a while and stays fresher than a bulk tub.
✅ Pros
- Calcium min. 20% — the higher of the two jars
- 4.8 stars from 467 ratings
- All-in-one formula, no separate vitamin dust needed
- 300+ bought in the past month
❌ Cons
- Higher cost per ounce than the 17.6 oz jar
- Runs out fast if you keep a large collection
Repashy Calcium Plus 17.6 oz. (1.1 lb) JAR
17.6 oz (1.1 lb) JAR | 4.8 stars (467 ratings) | Calcium min. 17% | Vitamin D min. 20,000 IU/lb
- Our Calcium Carbonate is mined from the Mohave Desert in California, where it was deposited...
For a multi-reptile setup, this is the jar I’d buy. It works out to check current price on Amazon per ounce, which is a big drop from the 6 oz rate, and the 1.1 lb tub means you’re not reordering every few weeks. Repashy says the calcium carbonate is mined in California’s Mohave Desert and micro ground to about 3.5 microns, which is what gives it that stick on dusted insects. The one thing to note: it lists calcium at a minimum of 17%, lower than the 6 oz jar’s 20%, so check what your species needs before going big.
✅ Pros
- Lowest cost per ounce of the two jars
- 1.1 lb tub lasts a long time across multiple reptiles
- 4.8 stars from 467 ratings
- Calcium micro ground to about 3.5 microns for better stick
❌ Cons
- Calcium min. 17% — lower than the 6 oz jar
- Bigger upfront outlay than the small jar
- Overkill if you only keep one reptile
Which One Should You Buy?
Honestly, the “best” jar comes down to how many mouths you’re feeding and how often you dust. I keep both sizes in mind depending on whether someone’s running a single gecko or a whole rack.
Repashy Calcium Plus 6 oz JAR is right for you if…
- You keep just one or two reptiles and want a jar that won’t sit around going stale.
- You want the higher calcium option at a minimum of 20% for your dusting routine.
- You’re new to Repashy and want to test the all-in-one formula before committing to a bigger tub.
Repashy Calcium Plus 17.6 oz. (1.1 lb) JAR is right for you if…
- You keep a real collection and dust insects several times a week across multiple tanks.
- You want the lowest cost per ounce so you’re not reordering constantly.
- You’re fine with a calcium minimum of 17% and the micro ground 3.5 micron texture that sticks well to feeders.
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you only keep a single reptile that eats prepared diets instead of live insects, you probably don’t need a dusting powder at all. And if you specifically need a plain calcium without D3 or added vitamins, a straight calcium carbonate product would serve you better than an all-in-one.
For the most common buyer — someone running a few geckos or a bearded dragon plus a couple of friends — I’d go with the 17.6 oz jar. The per-ounce savings add up fast when you’re dusting feeders every week.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Repashy Calcium Plus size is better for a multi-reptile collection?
For a multi-reptile setup, I’d pick the 17.6 oz jar every time. It works out to a much lower cost per ounce than the 6 oz, and the 1.1 lb tub means you’re not reordering every few weeks when you’re dusting feeders across several tanks. The only reason to go smaller is if you keep just one or two animals.
Is the 17.6 oz jar worth it over the 6 oz jar?
Yes, if you dust insects regularly. The 17.6 oz is priced at a noticeably lower rate per ounce than the 6 oz, so the savings compound the more you use. The trade-off is the higher upfront outlay and the fact that its calcium minimum is 17% versus 20% on the 6 oz jar.
Why does the 6 oz jar have more calcium than the bigger one?
Good catch — the 6 oz jar lists calcium at a minimum of 20%, while the 17.6 oz lists 17%. Both are all-in-one dusting powders with the same vitamins and trace minerals, but the guaranteed analysis differs between the two sizes. Check what your species needs before assuming the bigger jar is identical.
How long does each jar actually last?
That depends entirely on how many reptiles you feed and how often. The 6 oz jar has 300+ bought in the past month and suits a small collection, while the 17.6 oz is a 1.1 lb tub built for keepers dusting multiple times a week. For a single gecko, the 6 oz will last a long time; for a rack, the big jar is the practical choice.
Do both sizes have the same ingredients and formula?
They’re both Repashy Calcium Plus with calcium carbonate, dried kelp, brewer’s dried yeast, and the same vitamin blend including Vitamin D3 at a minimum of 20,000 IU/lb and Vitamin E at 2,000 IU/lb. The 17.6 oz also calls out calcium micro ground to about 3.5 microns for better stick on insects. The main difference I found is the calcium minimum: 20% on the 6 oz versus 17% on the 17.6 oz.
Should I buy the small jar first to try it?
If you’re new to Repashy, starting with the 6 oz is a smart way to test the all-in-one formula without committing to a big tub. Both sizes hold a 4.8-star rating from 467 reviews, so the quality is consistent. Once you know your reptiles take to it, step up to the 17.6 oz for the better per-ounce value.
My Final Verdict
After weighing both jars, the Repashy Calcium Plus 17.6 oz is my clear overall winner for multi-reptile keepers. Its lower cost per ounce and 1.1 lb tub make it the practical pick when you’re dusting feeders across several tanks, and it holds the same 4.8-star rating from 467 reviews as the small jar. The 6 oz is the better runner-up for anyone keeping just one or two reptiles, and its calcium minimum of 20% beats the big jar’s 17%.
If you’re on the fence, ask yourself how fast you’ll go through it. Dusting a single gecko a couple times a week? The 6 oz has you covered. Feeding a rack of lizards every week? The 17.6 oz pays for itself in per-ounce savings.
Winner: Repashy Calcium Plus 17.6 oz
- Our Calcium Carbonate is mined from the Mohave Desert in California, where it was deposited...
Best for keepers with multiple reptiles who dust insects often. The lower cost per ounce and 1.1 lb tub mean fewer reorders and better long-term value.
Runner-Up: Repashy Calcium Plus 6 oz
- Calcium min. 20%, Sodium min. 1%, Magnesium min. .3%, Manganese min. 350 mg/kg, Zinc min. 350 mg/kg...
Best for smaller collections or first-time buyers. It lists a higher calcium minimum of 20% and stays fresher if you don’t use much at a time.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.